THE PARADOX OF DIGITAL EMPOWERMENT AND COGNITIVE DEPENDENCE IN HIGHER EDUCATION: CRITICAL THINKING AND EVIDENCE-BASED PEDAGOGY IN UZBEKISTAN

Article Information

Download PDF

Abstract

This conceptual study examines a contradiction in the digital
transformation of higher education: wider access to generative artificial
intelligence (AI) may increase students’ ability to access information while
reducing the intellectual work involved in evaluating it. Through a critical
synthesis of recent scholarship and a documentary analysis of Uzbekistan’s
education and AI policy, the article distinguishes technological access from
epistemic agency, understood as a learner’s capacity to formulate questions,
scrutinise evidence and remain accountable for conclusions. It develops a
pedagogical mechanism comprising deliberate cognitive friction, evidence
triangulation, dialogic justification and reflective disclosure of AI use. The article
argues that foreign-language classrooms offer a productive setting for such
practices because linguistic interpretation, source evaluation and intercultural
reasoning can be assessed together. The proposed mechanism is a theoretically
grounded design proposition, not an experimentally validated intervention.

Keywords

critical thinking; epistemic agency; generative artificial intelligence; cognitive offloading; higher education; Uzbekistan; English language education.